I think that it is established that I
am the world’s worst mother. Over the years my kids have been happy to point
out all of my weaknesses and all of the things that that I did that they didn’t
like. Now that they are older they are a little more forgiving, but the truth
is, like all parents, I’ve injected plenty of my own personality into my
parenting, and sometimes that means I’ve come up short.
This has become even more apparent in recent days when I’ve
undertaken the huge project of getting everyone’s photo books updated. I began scrapbooks
for my three oldest many years ago, and I was pretty well caught up when we
moved into our current home ten years ago. Since then, I’ve done precious
little. I did put together a book for Kelsey during her senior year in high
school, but beyond that, stuff has just accumulated.
I began my career as a scrapbooker before the digital age,
and I kind of like the old school method of cutting and pasting, in part because
I’m comfortable with it and in part because I’m kind of tactile. But it
certainly has its drawbacks. It’s messy, and it takes up a lot of space, and I
don’t always have exactly what I want or need to complete a layout.
Plus I spend a lot of time sorting everything, especially photos.
With ten years of prints, this is no small feat. I ask my kids to help, and
sometimes they are actually helpful, but when they do, it isn’t always pleasant.
Sometimes they are annoyed because they
cannot BELIEVE that I don’t remember some of the details of the photos—things that
were clearly memorable to them. Sometimes they are peeved because, going
through the photos, they are reminded of a time when they felt shortchanged,
persecuted, or neglected: “Well, there was a year when I didn’t get to have a
birthday party.” Other times they are unhappy with the photo quality: “I look
terrible. Why would you include that?”
As we sort photos, I most regret the shots I didn’t get.
Sometimes I would run out of film or the batteries would die unexpectedly, but
sometimes I would just forget to grab the camera. I actually forgot the camera
for my oldest child’s high school graduation. Seriously, who does that? Some
days I really am a terrible excuse for a parent.
Assembling the books takes a lot of time and effort, and some
days I don’t know if I actually enjoy it. Right now I feel so much self-imposed
pressure to get it done that I’m not sure I’m loving it all that much, and I’m
not sure I’m doing the best job I could do. Of course, I have more experience
now, so I can do more on instinct. And since the idea is to highlight the
photos, I worry less about creative use of paper and stickers, and focus on the
pictures.
My other frustration is that writing in these books has
always been important to me: putting the photos in context, remembering cute
sayings or reactions, writing down the kids’ best friends or favorite foods. I’m
frustrated that so many memories have faded, making the writing perfunctory and
not as interesting as the captions I wrote when the assembly time was closer to
the actual date.
For the two younger kids, nearly all of our photos are
digital, so I’m considering doing digital books for them. There are lots of
advantages to the process: less mess for sure, less cost, more flexibility,
fewer mistakes. But there’s also less “me” in the books. The books won’t have
my terrible handwriting, my artistic style, my fingerprints on the photos. My
kids likely would appreciate a perfect book, just like they would appreciate a
perfect mother, but as they mature, the things they value may shift.
So maybe I’ll just keep doing it old school. Perfection—in projects
and parenting—is overrated.